Difference between revisions of "Category:Is-Philly Neighborhood"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m (minor improvement) |
m (minor improvement) |
||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
==Editor's Notes== | ==Editor's Notes== | ||
*I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan | *I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan | ||
− | *To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where | + | *To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where should be a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is should a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul |
[[Category:Is]] | [[Category:Is]] |
Revision as of 00:03, 28 December 2019
See Also
Editor's Notes
- I believe that more neighborhoods should be tagged with this category... -- Stan
- To me, it seems redundant as long as we stick to our category-naming conventions, i.e., when naming Wheres, it's a Philly 'hood if doesn't have a state abbreviation or the word "County", and it's not the name of a state or foreign country. Furthermore, all the neighborhood Wheres are subcats, so our Where-Philadelphia cat already singles them out from among the counties, states, and countries, and it provides easier-to-handle lists of neighborhoods by region (North Philly, West Philly, etc). What purpose would this cat serve? And, again, I'm very wary of cross-categorizing between Top Cats. I believe that every category that appears on a category page should be in the same top cat as the category page; a Where should be a subcategory to only other Wheres; an Is should a subcategory to only other Is's, etc. --Paul
Subcategories
This category has the following 37 subcategories, out of 37 total.