Difference between revisions of "Category talk:Is-Event"

From Wikidelphia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Ok, let's leave it as it is.)
Line 9: Line 9:
  
 
This category Is-Event doesn't even have anything in it, and it's too broad. Who would want such a list? I would keep the event categories as they are and perhaps add a cat to capture events that don't recur, like maybe Is-One_Time_Event, something like that. ~[[User:PaulSank|Paul]]
 
This category Is-Event doesn't even have anything in it, and it's too broad. Who would want such a list? I would keep the event categories as they are and perhaps add a cat to capture events that don't recur, like maybe Is-One_Time_Event, something like that. ~[[User:PaulSank|Paul]]
 +
----
  
== Ok, let's leave it as it is. ==
+
Ok, let's leave it as it is.
  
I agree that it's make work to change it. Let's leave Is-Event with the two pointers.[[User:Stan|Stan]] ([[User talk:Stan|talk]]) 04:48, 28 March 2017 (EDT)
+
I agree that it's make work to change it. Let's leave Is-Event with the two pointers.[[User:Stan|Stan]]

Revision as of 04:52, 28 March 2017

We might consider listing all events here and removing Is-Annual Event and Is-Recurring Event because the category Frequency deals effectively with the timing issue. ~Stan


It just sounds like extra work to me.

I think annual events are important enough to have their own category. Yeah, I can see that I've built this cat up to 41 pages. I don't want to have to go through 41 pages removing a category without a very powerful reason indeed. I see no harm or trouble in using three cats, Is-Annual_Event, Is-Recurring_Event, and Frequency-Annual for each such page.

This category Is-Event doesn't even have anything in it, and it's too broad. Who would want such a list? I would keep the event categories as they are and perhaps add a cat to capture events that don't recur, like maybe Is-One_Time_Event, something like that. ~Paul


Ok, let's leave it as it is.

I agree that it's make work to change it. Let's leave Is-Event with the two pointers.Stan